Hmm... it kinda sounds like someone overcharged the system to help compensate for the fact your compressor is on its last legs.

Thus far, my research is inconclusive as to whether the same compressor is used on both 1st-gen and 2nd-gen MINIs. If you find out they are, I have one from my old '02 MCS. I had to replace it in May '09, and it is a refurb unit. But it worked great until I wrecked it.
As for your refrigerant grumblings, yes, it does suck they keep changing the product. The problem is, no matter how friendly or unfriendly the refrigerant is, the common issue is it gets vented into the atmosphere. The law says you cannot do so whether intentional or accidental. The problem is many AC systems eventually degrade to the point they slowly leak or vent into the atmosphere without any human intervention. So, in essence, we are all guilty of accidental ventilation. Gotta love laws.
